Updated 5/14/2026
Sometimes, you want to sell cards to Card Kingdom, but looking over the mountains of cards you have, it seems too daunting a task. Rather than spending the time going through each card and seeing if it’s on our buylist, you can package everything up and send it to our Collections department.
Or maybe you’ve got some booster boxes or Commander decks taking up space. Or a bunch of non-English cards, or artist-signed cards, or anything Magic-related that isn’t on our buylist. Collections will handle all of that.
For example – normally, we don’t take altered-art cards…but when the original artist puts a few embellishments on a piece of Power, that’ll catch our attention.
We also normally don’t take cards that are below Good condition. But it’s hard to ignore iconic cards, even if they have seen better days.
And if you picked up a nifty piece of swag from an event, but just don’t have the room for it anymore, we can help you out there, too.
If you have questions about whether we will buy your items, let us know about it when you contact us!
How To Sell Cards with Collections
We’re excited to announce the relaunch of our Collections buying program, with an updated process built to better support high-value and specialized collections.
Start by Connecting with Our Team
To get started, email us at buyer@cardkingdom.com with details about your collection.
If you’ve worked with us before, welcome back. We’ve made some updates to the program and would love to work with you again.
What We’re Currently Buying
Right now, we’re focused on Magic: The Gathering and Pokémon products, including:
Magic: The Gathering
Oddities (autographs, errors, playtest cards)
Graded cards (CGC, PSA, BGS)
Vintage complete sets (NM/Mint/Pack fresh)
High-value collections (ideally sorted by set, alphabetically)
Reserved List cards
Serialized cards
Pokémon
Graded cards (CGC, PSA, BGS)
Vintage sets
Modern pack-fresh sets
Binder Collections
Sealed promos
Sealed booster boxes
What to Include
To help us review your collection quickly, try to include:
A general overview (size, game, era)
Photos or a spreadsheet, if you have one
Any standout or high-value items
What Happens Next
Once we’ve taken a look, a buyer will follow up to let you know which of our selling options is the best fit and walk you through next steps, including shipping or in-person review and general pricing expectations.