5 Underrated Commander Cards in Duskmourn

Jacob LacknerCommander

We are deep into spooky season, so I think it’s a good time to take a look at some cards from what is arguably Magic’s spookiest set – Duskmourn: House of Horrors. That set introduced us to the horrifying plane of Duskmourn in 2024. It’s ruled over by Valgavoth, a fear-eating Elder Demon who has expanded himself across the entire plane. To put it simply – Valgavoth is Duskmourn and Duskmourn is Valgavoth.

The plane is filled with horrors that he uses to torment all of his victims so that he can feed on their fear. The set features lots of modern horror tropes as a result.

The set was a hit in every way, and as such it has lots of cards that Commander players are very familiar with. Arabella is one of the most popular Commanders there is, and Withering Torment and Untimely Malfunction are both heavily played cards prized because of their flexibility.

However, as well-known as the set is, I think there are some cards that have gotten lost in the shuffle. In this article I’m going to take a look at five overlooked Duskmourn: House of Horror cards that should be seeing more play in Commander.

UNDERRATED COMMANDER: TYVAR, THE PUMMELER

Tyvar, the Pummeler
Tyvar, the Pummeler
Tyvar is the 1,779th Most Popular Commander on EDHRec at time of publication.

Duskmourn features a cycle of legendary creatures that each represent the common character archetypes in modern horror films. Tyvar is meant to represent the jock, and what a jock he is. He has an Overrun-like activated ability and he’s incredibly resilient since he can become indestructible for no mana at all. This makes it easier for him to stick around and use his activated ability to create imposing board states.

It’s not hard to build a good Tyvar deck because he’s great when you do the three things that Green decks already love to do – ramp mana, play high-power creatures, and go wide. He’s even an Elf if you want to lean into that.

For example, Tyvar works especially well with creatures like Ghalta, Primal Hunger – who love it when you have high power on the board. Tyvar’s activated ability can be used to make Ghalta insanely cheap and if he’s already on the board the buff from Tyvar’s ability will be completely absurd.

If I still haven’t convinced you, Tyvar is also part of a game-ending two-card combo that isn’t all that hard to assemble. If you have 3GG to use Tyvar’s ability, Devoted Druid will get the buff – and that means you can now put way more -1/-1 counters on it. So many that you can just use it to produce 5 more mana before using the buff again. This lets you buff your entire board as many times as you want, which will often produce lethal.

DEMONIC COUNSEL

Demonic Counsel
Played in 1.7% of Black Decks on EDHRec at the time of publication.

This card’s incredibly unsettling art represents Valgavoth manipulating a young woman named Marina Vendrell into casting a spell that freed him from his prison on the plane. 

I was pretty surprised when I saw how little this powerful Tutor is played. I mean sure, just tutoring up a Demon isn’t good enough in most decks. However, that’s the baseline, and the ceiling here is Demonic Tutor. Any Black graveyard deck worth its salt is going to be able to get Delirium online relatively early in the game too.

The trick to getting the most out of it is also having at least a couple of worthwhile Demon tutor targets, that way the floor on this card is a bit higher. The good news is there are all kinds of game-breaking demons who are worth running in Commander – from smaller ones like Bloodletter of Aclazotz to massive ones like Valgavoth himself.

ABHORRENT OCULUS

Abhorrent Oculus
Abhorrent Oculus
Played in 0.56% Of Blue Decks on EDHRec at the time of publication.

When I saw that only 0.56% of Blue Commander decks are using this card, my eyes just about popped out of my head! This massive, disembodied eye roams the plane’s Floodpits looking for victims to scare to death, and the card is also an absolute powerhouse – one that gets even better in Commander.

The manifest dread trigger happens at the beginning of each opponent’s upkeep, which means that in a typical 4-player Commander game you’re going to get three 2/2s with upside that also help you load your graveyard. That’s the kind of value that can just bury your opponents.

It is true that the additional cost here isn’t something all Blue decks are capable of paying for in the early game, but there are plenty of Blue decks that can, and every single one of them should be using the Oculus. 

The eye is at its best in decks that are either good at doing stuff with the graveyard or the manifest mechanic. For example, Zimone, Mystery Unraveler is a great option since she gives you even more manifest dread plus the ability to turn face down permanents face up. Teval is also a great fit with the Oculus, since it can quickly load your graveyard while also paying you off for exiling the cards with the Oculus’s additional cost.

GHOST VACUUM

Ghost Vacuum
Ghost Vacuum
Played in .49% of Decks on EDHRec at the time of publication.

The survivors of Duskmourn aren’t completely helpless. Many of them have managed to fashion weapons to fight the specters of the plane, like this Proton Pack-like device.

Ghost Vacuum is one of the best ways to hate on the graveyard in the entire game. It’s certainly slower than Tormod’s Crypt, but unlike the Crypt the Vacuum becomes a legitimate win condition later in the game as an army of flying 1/1 copies of all the creatures you exiled can often take over the game.

While it can work nicely in just about any deck, the Vacuum is at its best if you’re using a Commander who likes it when cards are exiled.

For example, Ketramose, the New Dawn draws you a card every time you exile something with Ghost Vacuum, and it’ll also be a lot easier for Ketramose to become a creature if you have the Vacuum around.

COME BACK WRONG

Come Back Wrong
Come Back Wrong
Played in .89% of Black Decks on EDHRec at the time of publication.

This card references the common horror trope of someone using black magic to bring someone back from the dead, but them coming back as a twisted, half-dead, frightening version of themself – like in Pet Sematary.

It conveys this flavor super well, since it lets you destroy a creature and then reanimate it on your side of the battlefield, but you only get it in play for that turn. The baseline here is a solid removal spell, and sometimes you can do something pretty powerful with the creature you get back.

While losing the creature so quickly limits what you can do with it, Commander has enough incredibly powerful creatures with strong “enters” triggers that you can take advantage of with this. Destroying an opposing Avenger of Zendikar or Atraxa, Grand Unifier goes a long way towards pulling you ahead in a game.

END STEP

Duskmourn is filled with lots of spooky and powerful cards that are even more fun in October. What Duskmourn card do you think is overlooked? Let me know on X or Bluesky.