The Hottest Commander Cards in Star Trek | Set Review

Kristen GregoryCommander

Star Trek is the latest Standard-legal Magic set and is available now. It’s a love letter to the classic Sci-fi franchise and covers all eras. This is our Set Review as far as Commander is concerned.

We covered our rundown of the best Commons and Uncommons in the set in our Pauper, pEDH & Commander roundup, so strap in and let’s dive right into the rares and mythics. We’ll cover the stronger Commanders and the cards great in the 99. 

You can find other recent set reviews here: 

Card Kingdom’s Set Reviews focus on the cards that bring the most value to your collection as a deckbuilder. If you notice something missing, chances are we’ve skipped over it because it’s just a bit niche. We want you to grab the strongest cards with the most potential for future deckbuilding. 

STAR TREK SET REVIEW: WHITE

Captain Jean-Luc Picard is a pretty good place to start for this round-up. He’s an anthem, creates tokens when you play you creatures and Spacecraft, and tutors said Spacecraft into play when you untap officers. He requires you to build around him and other officers to get the most value, but even getting a buff to the board for Stationing is good in a vacuum (like space… space is a vacuum). 

Deanna Troi, Psychic Counsel is an ideal two-drop for white decks, whether they’re focused on +1/+1 counters or just flooding the board, as she allows tokens to enter with counters, too. You can’t ask for much more for two mana, and if you’re not in green, she’s a slam dunk of a pick for your counters decks.

Dr. Beverly Crusher is a pretty huge pickup for lifegain decks. Getting to double up on lifegain triggered abilities means a lot more +1/+1 counters from Archangel of Thune and Lyra, Archangel of Dawn just for starters. While the best token producers in these decks are a delayed check during the End Step, you can still leverage Dr. Crusher to accelerate lifegain payoffs in a good number of decks. 

A good protection spell at two mana is always worth consideration, and The Needs of the Many is going to be better than the baseline (Dawn’s Truce) a good amount of the time. Getting the fog mode as well tips it past other two mana options, and the low entry cost of needing a creature in play isn’t that hard to meet. Flare of Fortitude is already highly played for being the “next best” catch-all to Teferi’s Protection, and this new spell is a good alternative option too.

Peace in Our Time is a new “win the game” card in white – let’s examine it. It’s four mana, and the base mode is basically a way to stop people attacking you by giving them cards. You can do the same, and each time that decision is made, it gets a peace counter on it. When you have twelve counters on it, your next upkeep gives you the win. 

It’s actually a pretty reasonable goal, getting to twelve counters. You’re not doing it organically though – you’ll need some proliferate action to help get you there. Definitely worth a shot!

STAR TREK SET REVIEW: BLUE

The Caretaker is the perfect payoff for playing lots of modal spells. Six mana might seem a lot, but with the Ward {2} and the fact it can trigger on every end step at the table, it starts to look a bit more fair. A free guaranteed spell even when it’s completely random is great. 

You get a lot of Magic card for two mana nowadays, and Gwyndala, the Progeny isn’t set to buck the trend. While the equipment it makes on entering is a pretty forgettable trinket, it’s that activated ability that really sings in the right decks. Turning all of your equipment tokens into your best non-legendary Equipment until end of turn wins games. Arna Kennerud players – enjoy. 

A three mana addition to the chaos-adjacent gift giving decks, Kobayashi Maru Scenario has some pretty decent modes. A bounce, two cards, and two tokens are good modes to enjoy while not being backbreaking to play against when you inevitably send this Enchantment to another player. More like the Kobayashi Zedruu Scenario. 

Lieutenant Commander Data is one of the better cards in the set, and he arrives to bolster all of the decks that use counters. He’ll excel the most when it comes to Saga Creatures (removing Lore Counters), but can slot into regular +1/+1 counters decks, too. Take note you can remove Finality counters this way, which is pretty hot. 

Lt. Cmdr. Geordi La Forge is a doubler, which generally speaking means someone will want him. What he doubles is charge counters – which is pretty niche. That said, with more and more Spacecraft being added to the game, his value will no doubt go up, even if you don’t necessarily need him for a deck right now.

The headline doubler in the set, though, is Mr. Spock, Science Officer. Teferi’s Ageless Insight is a widely played Enchantment that doesn’t even double your draw in your draw step, while Spock does. Sure, he’s a little more fragile, but that barely matters – you’re playing Spock for that sweet, sweet draw power. Likely going to be the main chase card of the set.

Seven of Nine, Unassimilated is an interesting one. You get to loot in your first main phase, and then that loot turns into drawing a card the moment you have five or more differently named lands. Eventually, she can become a 7/9 in the late game. What’s attractive here is the repeatable draw on a two-drop – much like the breakout uncommon of the set Anthropological Mission, you don’t really care about looting early, as you can use that to set up your graveyard. Two-drops are cranked these days, eh?

STAR TREK SET REVIEW: BLACK

Cryptbreaker sees play in Zombie decks for a very good reason – card draw on a one drop is very, very strong. Collation Trimatrix doesn’t make more artifact creatures – which would be broken given metalcraft and affinity exist – but it’s still contributing to both of those mechanics while coming down early. A really sweet include in low to the ground artifact decks that spam out creature tokens like Thopters and Servos. 

Death is Irrelevant is expensive to cast at eight mana but makes a strong case for splashing out on it as your top-end. It gives your artifact creatures Indestructible for a start, but the main attraction is arguably the assimilation of a creature from any graveyard. In decks with a lot of “communal” mill (looking at you, Mesmeric Orb), Death could be strikingly Relevant, actually. 

Elim Garak, Simple Tailor is the payoff for Dilemma decks. It’s not particularly deeper than “here’s a wincon/chip damage for doing your thing”, but it doesn’t have to be. Still, being a 3/3 Menace for three mana is above the rate I expected with this rules text.

Georgiou, Terran Emperor is quite the card. Six mana for a 4/6 Human Rogue Noble that stops you losing the game for having 0 life or less. It’s another Lich card, then, but what’s the gravy? Getting to lose 3 life, draw a card, and make ten 1/1 tokens on your end step. It might be a challenge to really get the most out of Georgiou as a Commander, but in other dedicated Lich decks as another adjacent effect and payoff, it’s going to be good.

Grand Nagus Zek is a grower if you’re a shower. Show him the money, and he’ll get feisty. What’s more, he’ll amass some coin all by his lonesome once per turn when another creature dies. Great in edict-heavy decks, and especially those that want to sacrifice creatures for value – they do quite often care about sacrificing creatures with high toughness or power. 

Gul Dukat, Colonial Prefect is a whopping seven mana – but is it worth it? I’d say so. He’s a 6/6 Menace that has a Wound Reflection effect on each end step. It’s already great that it triggers on each end step, but it gets better – you gain life equal to the life lost that way. That more than pays off the seven mana investment, as that extra life keeps you alive playing more aggressive strategies that damage each opponent. 

STAR TREK SET REVIEW: RED


Encounter the Unknown
is a pretty solid modal spell – you either get to impulse draw two cards until the end of your next turn, or you get to deal 2 damage to each creature and player. Early game sweepers are seeing more relevance in Commander nowadays as curves get leaner and more aggressive, and a Pyroclasm can often do a surprising amount of work. Don’t forget – this can be amplified like any other form of damage.

Lwaxana Troi, Charming Guest is what you get if you ask Strionic Resonator to be a one-time payment, but always online. Yeah – you read that right. While Lwaxana is gated by summoning sickness, she can perma-Resonate any triggered abilities of a creature of your choice while she remains tapped and in play. If you’re all in on a Commander, Lwaxana looks frightfully powerful. 

Pah-Wraith is another new finisher in the vein of Craterclaw Colossus. If you’re ramping rather than playing artifacts, this might be the better option – though arguably only when you don’t want to play Craterhoof Behemoth or Moonshaker Cavalry. It’s the First Strike that really matters here – for keyword soup decks. 

Q, Stacking the Deck is one of the most exciting Commanders in the set. When he enters, you essentially get to get as many copies as you like of a random spell from your deck. You can absolutely stack the deck here to make it more predictable (hola, Sensei’s Divining Top) – and potentially set up some combos. 

Quark, Humble Proprietor is an interesting one to figure out. He stops you sacrificing treasures but helps to build you up a strong supply – up to four per rotation of the table. Provided you have a way to bounce, sacrifice or destroy him, you can use this to your advantage – though for just how long you save up and forego casting more spells is a tricky one, as you could get blown out while waiting. 

Worf, Intelligence Contractor is a heck of a theft effect. You get up to three mana value three creatures (one from each opponent) until end of turn, and they gain haste and the Warrior typing (relevant for the Klingon deck at the very least). This is a premium rate threaten, and right up your street if you’re playing a deck like Hofri Ghostforge or a deck that copies creatures – think about Rionya, or Jaxis. 

STAR TREK SET REVIEW: GREEN

Branching Timeline is a big, stupid green sorcery. Like most other big, stupid green sorceries, it splurges permanents onto the table. By the time you cast this, X is likely to be around 6 (provided you’re playing some Basics and mana dorks). Is it worth it to reveal just the top 6 for eight mana? Probably not, so you need to dream bigger and play this in lands decks or Gates decks to truly cash out.

Captain Kathryn Janeway is a great alternative to Oracle of Mul Daya if you’re playing Humans – and even if you’re not, let’s be honest. Instead of getting to play lands off the top, you get to chew through your library with Explore triggers and grow your team. A deceptively simple card, but one that’ll be very good.

Dr. Joseph M’Benga is another doubler – we seem to have doubled the amount of doublers in this set, dawg, or something. Anyways, the main part we like here is the granting hexproof to the rest of the board if they have counters on them. That’s pretty hot, and well worth a look given its stapled to a doubler. 

Genesis Device is an intriguing alternative to other ramp options. Digging out a Planet has big potential depending on your deck, but let’s be honest – you’re playing this because it’s stapled to an “in case of the need to Scapeshift, break glass” button. Efficient. Economical. 

Jadzia Dax is a hell of a mana dork. She grows over the course of the game and can even grow herself by pitching cards. With any kind of +1/+1 counters synergy, proliferation, or other buffs, Jadzia quickly gets out of control. 

Finally, we round up our green cards with Stable Wormhole. It allows you to ramp by one tapped land when you attack – with the new tech of making a Planet land token. It fixes mana and gets a lot better if you’re taking extra combats or doubling your attack triggers. I like Stable Wormhole, and I think it’ll perform pretty well – especially if you start getting clever copying tokens.

STAR TREK SET REVIEW: MULTICOLOR, ARTIFACTS & LAND

Captain Benjamin Sisko is a pretty good Commander for a Dilemmas deck. While you could find homes for the payoffs and enablers in other decks, Sisko makes a strong case for being the chosen Commander. He provides quite a steady stream of Officer tokens for playing your modal cards and has a Golos-esque mana sink for later in the game. He basically accelerates you toward inevitability and can play with all kinds of tokens synergies along the way. 

Borg Cube is pretty exciting. It can come down heavily discounted, exiling an annoying creature, one you want to steal, or maybe just your own that you want to re-use the EtB ability of. You get to Assimilate once you’ve Stationed it, but crucially, that’s not all you get – you also get to jump the rest of the artifact creatures on your team. This makes it one of the better Spacecraft in my book. 

The City on the Edge of Forever is a Saga I can get behind. You phase out the whole board, and you can keep it phased out provided you somehow avoid sacrificing or otherwise losing the 0/1 Human token the saga makes that stops things phasing in. You eventually get to draw two cards and deal life loss to your opponents, while gaining life on the last mode and (usually) having everything phase back in. This is rife for shenanigans, but at baseline just buys you time for a good rate.

Dathon, His Heart Open brings enchantress – specifically Sagas – in a specifically Temur flavor. He gets to add counters to enchantments, helping push along your Sagas to their next chapters. While this part of his kit is a little undercooked compared to other options, his card draw coupled with burn is the opposite. Really strong option for an Enchantress Commander.

Hit It! might well be straight up better than Rhythm of the Wild. It gives your stuff haste while also ramping you (most of the time) and filling your graveyard (Jund decks are going to love this one). Personally, I feel it’s gonna be the surprise Hit of the set that ages really well. 

Kira Nerys, Firebrand is a really fun build. You can check out our in depth article on her here, but suffice to say, she’s a spicy Boros pick. Jacob also has his round up of the Coolest Commanders in Star Trek, with extended thoughts on some of the cards we covered today. 

Deep Space 9 is the new premier top-end for artifacts decks, big mana decks, and graveyard decks. The trigger is like getting an Etali trigger on each of your upkeeps provided enough of your deck is permanents. Won’t work in absolutely every deck, but a great engine if you’re playing enough permanents. 

Rounding things out today is Replicator. This can replicate your Planet land tokens for starters – and any other tokens you make. It naturally has a home in Food decks, but also does some fun stuff in decks that make tokens repeatedly. 

END STEP

And that’s our look at the Hottest Cards from Star Trek for Commander. Plenty of cards here for the average brewer, and some really strong two-drops in particular. I think that’s where we’re at now with two-drops – they’re the harbingers of more power creep. How do you like the set?