Gathering around the table for a night of Magic is more than just slinging spells. It’s about camaraderie, chaos, and maybe a little bit of competitive salt. Whether you’re a seasoned Planeswalker or a newcomer still figuring out how Counterspell works, these tips from our amazing team of Magic lovers will help you level up your game night.
Setting the Scene: Vibe Check
Seating: Floor or Chair?
Some swear by sitting on the floor like a group of meditating sages. There’s something freeing about being low to the ground, unbound by the tyranny of uncomfortable chairs. Others prefer the classic table setup. Either way, make sure everyone’s comfy. After all, nobody wants to Stasis their back mid-game.
Soundtrack of the Multiverse
Background music is key, but keep it at a volume where players can still hear the all important “In response…” without shouting. A little “Enter the Infinite” ambiance never hurt anyone. Just don’t let it drown out the game.
TV? More Like Time Walk (Don’t Do It)
Resist the urge to throw on Lord of the Rings in the background. Yes, even if it’s the extended edition. It’s a distraction, and before you know it, someone’s missed their trigger because they were too busy watching Gandalf yell at a Balrog.
Fueling the Fire: Snacks & Hydration
Greasy Fingers vs. Pristine Sleeves
Pizza is delicious, but it’s the sworn enemy of double sleeved foils. Opt for sandwiches, bread bowls, or the genius move of using chopsticks for chips. Less grease, more game. And for the love of Sol Ring, keep napkins and wipes on standby.
Hydrate or DIE drate
Soda and energy drinks are fine, but water is the real Heroic Intervention against next day regret. Bonus: It keeps you sharp when someone tries to pull off a Thassa’s Oracle combo at 1 AM.
Fruit: The Ultimate Untapped Mana
Strawberries, grapes, and watermelon are clutch. They’re light, refreshing, and won’t leave your playmat looking like a Goblin Bombardment aftermath.
Game Night Logistics: Keeping It Fresh
Mix Up the Formats
Commander is king, but switching to Pauper, Cube Draft, or even Star for five player chaos keeps things spicy. Consistency is key. Schedule regular nights so your crew treats it like a Rhystic Study trigger (“Do you pay the one?”).
Deck Draft: The Ultimate Chaos Shuffle
Everyone throws their decks into the pool, then drafts them. Hate draft your friend’s Urza monstrosity or try out that janky Squirrel Tribal list you’ve been eyeing. Just remember to return the decks afterward. No Thieving Skydiver shenanigans.
Precons for the Win
Bringing in new players? Keep it fair with precons or Battle Decks. Nobody enjoys getting Cyclonic Rifted into oblivion before they even understand the stack.
House Rules & Etiquette
Phones: Pocket ‘Em or Defenestrate ‘Em
Nothing kills the vibe faster than someone scrolling during their turn. Keep phones tucked away unless you’re checking rulings.
Clean Up & Contribute
If you’re a guest, bring snacks or drinks to share. And always help clean up. Nobody wants to wake up to a battlefield of empty cans and Food Tokens strewn across the table.
Bonus Round: Silly & Spicy Ideas
- Anti Draft: Build the worst deck possible, then swap with a friend and try to win anyway.
- $1 Commander Challenge: Build a deck where your commander costs $1 or less. Basic lands don’t count. Jank and budget friendly.
- Recordable Buttons: Pre load them with iconic phrases like “Are you gonna pay the one?” or “GAME CHANGER!” for maximum hilarity.
End Step
There you have it, your guide to crafting the perfect Magic night. Now go forth, shuffle up, and may your topdecks be as clutch as a Miraculous Recovery.
What’s your favorite game night tip? Share it on our social media. We’re always looking for new ways to Chaos Warp our play sessions into greatness.
Haelee has been a dedicated Magic: The Gathering player since 2003, she enjoys Commander, and regularly plays with her friends. With 14 years of experience in marketing, creative writing, and a background in theater tech, she brings a unique perspective to both her gameplay and storytelling. Known for her creative mind and deep appreciation for Magic’s lore, Haelee resides in Washington state with her wife, and cats.